Votes Have Value!
2024 Magazine
The ESG Wars Rage On!
Q2 2024
New! Subscribe for Early Access only $245 per year!
Optimizer Online
Recent Articles
Reader Alert: “Endemic Sloppiness” In 2024 AGM Materials
As most readers know, we think, our ‘sister company’ – CT Hagberg LLC - fields a team of 45 expert Inspectors of Election who, through July, will have served at well over 500 companies. This – plus your two editors’ own stock portfolios – causes us to monitor over 700 AGMs a year. This season, we were literally bowled over by the large number of flubs we encountered. The most common cause seems...
The Top Two VSMs – One Middlin’ One – And One “Most In Need Of Improvement” Of The 2024 VSMs We Monitored
The Top-Two 2024 VMs – A Two-Way Tie Between Citi And Verizon AT CITIGROUP – A WELL-RUN, HIGHLY ENGAGING AND INFORMATIVE EXPERIENCE…We were especially anxious to tune in the Citigroup VSM this year because we are huge fans of CEO Jane Fraser and continue to bet that at long last, this able “jockey” will be able to rein in the wild and crazy value-destroying horse that Citi has been for so long....
Drops In Retail Investor Voting Continue: A Four-Alarm Fire, We Say – Start Now On Plans To Do Better
We have been writing about the drop in retail investor voting ever since the Notice and Access model went into effect. We have no beef with the IDEA behind the “model” – which has saved literally billions of dollars for issuers – but we can see that it has become a major contributor to the now scarily low levels of proxy voting by ordinary investors, who once voted over 70% of their shares. Now,...
The ‘Biggest New Thing?’- A Double-Binding Bylaw Proposal
Activist investor Michael Levin and the editor of The Activist Investor (TAI) - inspired by the Tesla-proposed settlement of Musk’s comp-case to allow a (non-binding) vote on DIRECTOR COMPENSATION has since filed binding bylaw proposals to require shareholder approval of Director pay at 12 companies. Of the twelve companies, five will include it on the AGM agenda and in the proxy materials:...
Holy Moley! Exxon’s Suit Vs. Former Proponents, Followed By A Three-Page Screed In Their Proxy Statement, Draws Anger – And Two Exempt Solicitations As The AGM Ramps Up. Who’ll Stop The Madness Here?
Initially, we were sort of on board with the lawsuits Exxon filed against two shareholder proponents to ‘teach them a lesson’ to be more thoughtful about filing shareholder proposals. And yes, we are very much in sympathy with the idea that there are way too many shareholder proposals these days that have little chance of passing and that will not make any material difference in the day-to- day...
Our Take On The Disney Contest: Much To Ponder And To Learn From We Say
The Walt Disney Company released the official vote counts on April 4th from its 2024 meeting of shareholders held April 3rd - much faster than it usually takes to do so, we were happy to note - where they said “investors decisively defeated” the campaign by activist investor Nelson Peltz to win two seats on its board. Here are our own “key takeaways” from the contest, ranked roughly in order of...
How And When To Properly Open And Close The Polls
Over the last two years a mini-debate broke out sporadically over LinkedIn on how best to manage the opening and closing of the polls. Many activist investors felt that they should remain open until after the general Q&A period - and ideally, until the very end of the Meeting - so voters would have time to change their minds if something they heard rubbed them the wrong way. Quite a few...
A Few More Observations From The 2022 Meeting Battlefront – And Some “Problem Areas” To Note
The problem of “meeting congestion” on the busiest meeting dates continues to be a growing issue for issuers - and for their key suppliers: We predict that issuers will increasingly have to vie for favorable meeting dates and times, since at best, there are only eight hours in a given day when companies can safely hold their meetings without riling up shareholders - and directors too. So start...
Morrow Sodali Celebrates 50 Year Anniversary By “Building Together”
The OPTIMIZER interviews Adam Frederick, Global President, Bill Ultan, Managing Director – Corporate Governance and Greg Reppucci, Senior Director– Sustainability & Corporate Governance Through a combination of savvy strategic acquisitions and a continued focus on internal personnel growth and technological innovation, Morrow Sodali has been at the center of the most urgent and critical...
Will ‘Big Brother’ Really Be Looking At Your VSMs This Year?
We have been reporting on comments from ISS - and from several large investors as well - that they would be monitoring Virtual Shareholder Meetings to assure that shareholders will have a meaningful chance to ask questions - and to “engage in a dialogue with management” - and will consider voting against some or maybe even all directors in 2023 at companies that fail to meet these objectives. So...
When Pigs Fly
Ever hear this old expression, to indicate a totally unlikely event? Well damned, if pigs aren’t indeed flying high - on the proxy voting front! More kudos to Liz Dunshee for reporting that activist investor Carl Icahn’s fight for the rights of pregnant pigs not to be confined to cramped “gestational pens” will move forward to votes at McDonalds - and at Kroger, where Icahn is putting two...
The 2022 Season Starts Out With A Big Bang
As Liz Dunshee reported in her March 13 blog, “This voting outcome arrives at the same time that the UN Environment Assembly has agreed to negotiate a legally binding treaty to tackle plastics, which many are calling the next ‘Paris Accord.’ That comparison is significant because the targets in the Paris Treaty jump-started the focus on emissions. Meanwhile, other companies are proactively...
Shareholder Services: History
Carl Hagberg
The Shareholder Service OPTIMIZER, first published in 1994, is “dedicated to helping public companies – and their suppliers – to deliver better and more cost-effective services to shareholders”.
Get the Optimizer!
Subscribe to the Optimizer quarterly newsletter and bonus annual magazine - packed with investment insight, interviews with industry leaders, and much more!
The OPTIMIZER comes with the promise of "some free consulting on any shareholder relations or shareholder servicing matter to ever cross your desk.
Share
Share the Optimizer with your colleagues!